When the new owners finally took control of the club, many fans expected swift changes, particularly with the imminent handover of the new stadium. The long-awaited arrival of both the ownership and stadium was seen as a sign of a fresh start, with the new regime embracing the club’s iconic motto: Nil satis nisi optimum. This set the stage for hopes of a complete transformation.
Yet, more cautious supporters recognized that the new owners were unlikely to act hastily. There were valid reasons for keeping Sean Dyche in charge during the early stages of the ownership transition, and possibly even beyond, through the end of the transfer window. Despite the team’s current struggles, the owners might prefer a measured approach rather than reacting impulsively to the club’s poor form.
One argument in Dyche’s favor is that he could be the right manager to steer Everton clear of relegation, just as he did last season despite the massive setback of two points deductions. Based on this, some might suggest that he should remain at the helm until the end of the season when his contract expires. However, putting faith in another great escape, as seen in the past two seasons, could be tempting fate and prolonging the inevitable.
Football’s unpredictability makes any outcome uncertain, but Dyche’s primary issue has been his inability to generate enough attacking threat to win games. The team often seems more focused on defensive resilience, hoping for goalless draws rather than actively pursuing victory. This defensive-minded approach was clear once again in Saturday’s defeat to Bournemouth, where the game was decided by a late volley from Brooks.
Next week offers a chance for temporary redemption with an FA Cup tie at home to Peterborough United. A win could offer a brief respite from the mounting negativity surrounding the club. However, with the BBC moving the match to Thursday night (only available via iPlayer), the risk of an embarrassing upset increases. If Everton were to fall victim to a giant-killing in what could be the last-ever FA Cup game at Goodison Park, the backlash against Dyche and his coaching staff would likely be overwhelming.
